Northern California revealing that only three counties (Los Angeles, Orange, and Riverside) accounted for 83 of the state's death sentences in 2009. The justice system is comprised of human beings. Murder cases become death eligible through the existence of certain aggravating factors which make one murder "worse" than another. For example, in Florida, a defendant's odds of receiving a death sentence are.8 times higher if the victim was white than if the victim is black in similarly aggravated cases. Unlawful and Malicious, But Without Premeditation or DeliberationG. Pennsylvania Death Penalty Assessment Report (2007) Study by the American Bar Association (ABA) showing that flaws in Pennsylvania's death penalty system are so pervasive that the state risks executing an innocent person. Criminal Justice Data from the Administrative Office of the Courts We obtained our list of homicide cases from the North Carolina Administrative Office of the Courts (AOC) in Raleigh. Their spurious reasons for excluding black jurors were exposed by the Florida Supreme Court in reviewing the death penalty conviction of Robert Roundtree.
We also randomly sampled 10 of the 181 second-degree murder cases that received a sentence of life; we are finalizing data gathering on these 18 cases and they will be included in subsequent analyses. 15 None have examined data from cases as recent as those covered by the three latter years of the new North Carolina study (which spans the years from ). In Missouri, Judge Earl Blackwell issued a signed press release about his judicial election announcing his new affiliation with the Republican Party while presiding over a death penalty case against an unemployed African-American defendant. In addition to these non-statutory aggravating circumstances of the victim, we were also interested in accounting for the non-statutory aggravating features of the offense itself, including whether the offense involved multiple gunshot wounds, multiple victims, sniper killing etc. The first study documents the infectious presence of racism in the death penalty, and demonstrates that this problem has not slackened with time, nor is it restricted to a single region of the country. 12 Through an analysis of murders in which the death penalty could have been sought, it is possible, through an analysis of the defendants that were and were not sentenced to death, to assign a predictive score, or coefficient, to various aggravating factors to measure. In this groundbreaking study, the researchers reviewed all first-degree murder cases in the state between 19They found that 92 percent of the 544 first-degree murder cases in that time span contained at least one aggravating factor that made the defendant eligible for the death penalty. Eight UNC Law graduates from the class of 2000, after extensive training, were employed full-time as data coders.
Death Penalty and The Baldus Study
In the death penalty trial of Ramon Mata in Texas, the prosecutor and the defense attorney agreed to excuse all prospective minority race jurors, thereby ensuring an all white jury. Baldus,., Arbitrariness and Discrimination in the Administration of the Death Penalty: A Challenge to State Supreme Courts, 15 Stetson Law Review 133, 159-60, 163-64 (1986 and in the works of Gross Mauro, note 22 above; see also ABA Report, note 21 above,. State Studies, the following list is a sample of recent state studies focusing on issues two Authors Who Overcame Major Life Obstacles of the death penalty. Implementation of these laws necessarily requires discretionary judgments. As a result of these practices, although African-Americans were the victims of 65 of the homicides in the Chattahoochee Judicial District, 85 of the capital cases were white victim cases. Blackmun The way that racial bias can play out in practice is illustrated by one of the key death penalty jurisdictions in the country: Georgia's Chattahoochee Judicial District, which has sent more people to death row than any other district in the state. At level 6 severity, the difference was 15 percentage points, and at level 4 severity, the difference in death sentencing rates was 11 percentage points higher for black defendants. In the Philadelphia study, the racial combination which was most likely to result in a death sentence was a black defendant with a nonblack victim, regardless of how severe the murder committed. We have required instead that they establish that the system under which they were sentenced posed a significant risk of such an occurrence." Brennan repeatedly argued when race and death are linked, as the Baldus study demonstrated, the Court should demand the highest scrutiny. The researchers stated: "In the face of these results, we consider it implausible that the estimated disparities are a product of chance or reflect a failure to control for important omitted case characteristics. In 82 percent of the studies, race of victim was found to influence the likelihood of being charged with capital murder or receiving the death penalty,.e., those who murdered whites were found to be more likely to be sentenced to death than those who.
Character of Ben in Arthur Millers Death of a Salesman, Black Death of Europe,